Gallow Green New York Tripadvisor Reviews - Gallow Green New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Gallow Green New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Gallow Green New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Gallow Green New York
Gallow Green New York Tripadvisor Reviews
Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor
21 Reviews
0 Replys |
Unique and Delicious
Delicious food, friendly service, and wonderful outdoor atmosphere! Such a unique place - the history of the building is incredible and you feel like you are in an enchanted forest while eating. Good for a date or big group. Portions were big too! A+ overall.
Be the first to ReplyWonderful Rooftop Experience
Together with my seven-year-old daughter, we spontaneously went to Gallow Green from the High Line on 4 September in the late afternoon because of the heat. With luck we also got a place to eat. The place itself is just gorgeous in the summer. The menu is not set up with classic dishes - one or the other might have a hard time with that. We were really taken with the quality. The price is definitely anything but cheap - we definitely think it's justified. However, it would be nice to have alternatives for children in the menu. A special shout-out to Claire - she delighted me and especially my daughter with her service! We would come back to the Gallow Green anytime just for her. We will definitely visit this great rooftop bar again next time we visit New York City. Greetings from germany. Mario
Be the first to ReplyPerfect before Sleep No More!
We had an excellent dinner at Gallow Green before visiting the McKittrick Hotel for Sleep No More. We happened to be there for NYC restaurant week, so we enjoyed the pre-fixe menu for $60. I got the cheese curds and Scottish Salmon. Both were delicious! The salmon was cooked perfectly and paired with a creamy tahini and fresh vegetables. I finished with the chocolate mousse (absolutely divine!) and a frozen espresso martini. My friend had the heirloom salad (I tried and it was so refreshing!), the Buddha Bowl, and the orange panna cotta. The rooftop is very aesthetically pleasing. It makes a great setting for a meal. The server seemed like he just got broken up with or received bad news before we sat - he wasnโt particularly joyful or friendly. Overall, though, we had a wonderful visit and weโd happily go back again.
Be the first to ReplyCute and nice vibe brunch buffet!
Been here twice cause I love the vibe! I personally preferred when I went last Autumn when itโs a little bit colder! I had the brunch buffet which is $72 per person! Location: It is located in Chelsea near Highline. Itโs outdoor rooftop seating which I love!! I prefer when I went last Autumn because itโs much colder, this summer is too hot! Lol there is a lot of plants that are instagram worthy! Service: they are super nice and attentive! They will assist you on how the buffet works. Food: Everything was delicious! Itโs brunch buffet so there are assortments of breads, bagel, yogurt, spreads, salads, sweets. My personal favorite is their Carving station which includes the PORCHETTA: i love it, its a roast pork and the skin is so crispy! The meat is tender and flavorful. Another favorite is WHOLE SALMON: the salmon is so good and fresh! Flavored it well with seasoning! Mimosas were amazing too! Price rating: 8/10, it was not bad for food that you will get. $72 per person Definitely will come back here once it gets colder!! My fave is the carving station!
Be the first to ReplyShocker - terrible food
I ordered a Tuna Nicoise Salad. It came out pretty quickly which was good. The salad consisted of a bowl of roquette lettuce with literally one baby potato, half a boiled egg and a couple of cherry tomatoes - no tuna. After some fuss it went back to the kitchen. The same salad came back a while later with a very small amount of tuna on top of the same same salad. For $30 it was a disgrace. We had booked the show and went there for connivence but left hungry. With so many good restaurants in the area - avoid this one at all costs. They do a song and dance to try and create a feeling of excitement when you arrive. This is just annoying but whatever - they should save that and invest in their food and some chefs. Waste of a good fit out.
Be the first to ReplyNot worth it
Definitely would not go back. Very small portions and such a limited menu. I ordered an aperol spritz and it came in what looked like half the size of any other restaurant's wine glass. They had no red chili flakes, no bread, and they ran out of coffee! Felt rushed to leave. Not worth the effort nor the money.
Be the first to ReplyAwesome place for a company event
Came here with a large group of coworkers. The location was strangeโฆ you would not think there would be a restaurant here, but as Iโve realized about NYC, these gems are hidden from view. The whole group got whisked away on a freight elevator on the 7th floor (rooftop, I think), where it was nicely decorated and had a wonderful ambiance. Our dinner was buffet style and we had the bar. Great food, awesome staff. After a couple of hours we down to the 6th floor where you can get the older NYC subway vibe with the decorations. We took the elevator from there, walked out to the street to what felt like an alley (with graffiti on the wall and really nothing that resembled a trendy restaurant). Got on our shuttle and off we went. We had a great time. Definitely recommend.
Be the first to ReplyNice place
Pretty rooftop restaurant at the McKittrick Hotel (where they have different types of performances) with decent food and a good champagne (not by the glass, but they have half bottles). Nice staff.
Be the first to ReplyAbsolutely overrated!
Unfortunately, the restaurant is completely overrated. As soon as you enter, a "theater" is staged, as if you were entering the most desirable location in the city. However, the atmosphere, decor and food are anything but "top". The decor of the restaurant is rather outdated, a lot of odds and ends and didn't look nice to us. I was sitting on an old rickety wooden chair and I had the feeling that it was going to break at any moment. We ordered an appetizer. Unfortunately the main course came first and then the starter. The food was ok but not good value for money. The aperitif tasted like "kids punch". The service was friendly and quick. Nevertheless, we would not visit the restaurant again.
Be the first to ReplyLovely summer jazz al fresco vibe
A NY summer institution from what I understand. Popped in for cocktails and beers on a sticky summer evening. Great vibe, lovely live music, very hipster with super relaxed service. Maybe has become a bit touristy than it used to be, but recommended nonetheless
Be the first to ReplyTrapped in the Gallows
Pre-covid, Gallow Green had a very special sheen, elegant, artful and eager but not stuffy service and food that was good and presented well. Tonight's dinner was a complete disappointment. The spaces were dusty and dingy, and the actual eating area looked like a cheaply thrown together backyard tent you'd find in a suburban strip mall -- there was literally an animal hide that looked stapled to a shabby curtain (for ambiance?). The service was not even mediocre. It's always funny/sad to see waitstaff who act like they're somehow above the clientele. In finer places it's warranted, and comes from a pride of being there, working there, representing the establishment. From the receptionist who, Airpods on, didn't look up from his cell, to the waiter who disappeared again and again, to being placed near the restroom door, in an empty room. I know it's been a challenge to find people to fill positions in many corners of the work force, but oy! The food we ordered was terrible. Oh my god, beyond bad, stringy fish and chips, and picture this, a side of mashed potatoes served in a, wait for it, a skillet(!), for $10 that was literally, instant mashed potatoes with a trace of parmesan on it. My dining companion had a salad that looked like a bad Sweetgreen knock off, and at twice the price -- was that shredded cheese on top of the salad, the kind you'd use for a pizza?. Calamari was greasy in a very, very bad way. Maybe Gallow Green will find its footing again, but then again, who'd really want to step foot in it to find out? It's sweet to have nice memories, but there is no reward in trying to revisit by way of nostalgia in the dismal, cheerless fade of Gallow Green.
Be the first to ReplyGracious and Accomodating
My husband and I and a friend visited the Gallow Green on Thursday night. When we arrived I found out that there are stairs to the rooftop restaurant which is not ideal for our friend who is wheelchair-bound. The staff and management went above and beyond to accommodate us. They opened the street-side eating area just for us. The food was excellent especially the orange pannacotta. I can not say enough good things about Victoria the manager who made things happen and our server was excellent as well. We most appreciate all the effort and care that went into our evening.
Be the first to ReplyWhat a fantastic night out in NYC!
We had a party of 10 last night at the restaurant. An amazing experience and great food. Sitting outside on the rooftop was lovely. The service was phenomenal! A huge shout out to Daryl who was in charge of our group. He was wonderful!
Be the first to ReplyFun Cocktails and Atmosphere
Went for a late night dinner. It was a beautiful summer evening so sitting outside amongst all the foliage and flowers made for a dreamy dinner. The cocktails are pricey but this I expected in NYC and they were fun and unique drinks so we didn't mind terribly. We had calamari and fish and chips and both were very good.
Be the first to ReplyFavorite hidden nyc spot
One of my favorite rooftops in nyc. What it lacks in location and views is made up with great food, atmosphere, decor and cocktails. They sometimes have live music experiences usually acoustic and calm.
Great place for Sunday morning brunch
Rude hostess and inaccurate online information
I had high hopes for this place but instead we had a terrible experience. We went there for brunch. I checked the menu the night before and there was no indication of a fixed menu. The staff at the street level were nice but the hostess was rude and snobby. She told us the menu is $60 per person fixed and when I told her there was nothing about it online she was like I don't know. She couldn't care less. The place was empty and there wasn't any one waiting after us so she wasn't in a rush, but she told us: "so what is it? drinks or down" while pointing fingers to bar and elevator. She just wanted us out of there.
Hostesses are the front face of restaurants when they aren't welcoming and don't care, what do you expect from the rest?
Also the bar area has no sitting or views.
Nice hidden spot
Simple dishes, small cabin space could work on the charm. Limited menu but ok and reasonably priced items to share.
Scotch egg was way over cooked and pork pie in pastry should not be served cold.
Unique brunch in the winter lodge
My sister and I had brunch here the morning after we attended Sleep No More. It was a fun way to spend more time โin that world,โ discuss our experiences from the night before, and of course have a delicious meal in a rooftop lodge that looks like it came from another time. The service was impeccable and the meal was great! Iโd love to go back in the summer but we had a great experience at the winter lodge.
Be the first to ReplyNot What Expected
This was disappointing as online it looks to be so much nicer than it is. I feel like itโs a bit deceiving.
We ate in a very dark corner, no indication that we were on a rooftop. The recent menu change a vast improvement though, food was good. Itโs getting a lot more press than it deserves. Wonโt be back.
Beautiful venue on a fall evening!
We loved being on the rooftop on a brisk fall evening. Beautifully decorated with lights and fall decor. We had a private area in the rail car and by the fire. Delicious appetizers, good beer and wine choices too. Would return again and again!
Be the first to ReplyUnique and a gorgeous Oasis in the city
My friend had her wedding breakfast here and it was absolutely fab!
The pizza is DEVINE, really great atmosphere and it's decor is fab! Even on a cold night you can warm yourself by the fire.
I would really recommend this place!