Prince St. Pizza New York Yelp Reviews - Prince St. Pizza New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Prince St. Pizza New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Prince St. Pizza New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Prince St. Pizza New York
Prince St. Pizza New York Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
56 Reviews
0 Replys |
Stopped here for lunch while working in the area.
The pizza was delicious, it was ready quickly and we were able to sit outside. Definitely worth checking out if you're nearby.
Be the first to ReplyWas expensive as it cost like 8$ per slice however I think
Was expensive as it cost like 8$ per slice however I think it was worth it!! The fluffy pillowy dough is unmatched and pairs well with the sauce! I'm a sauce girly and this definitely hits!
Be the first to ReplyA solid spot for late-night eats -- they have really nailed
A solid spot for late-night eats -- they have really nailed the Detriot-style slices! It gets pretty busy, but the line moves quickly. There's no room to eat inside, so would grab a takeout box. Definitely one of the more popular slice shops in NY, worth a try!
Be the first to Replyhands down the best pizza i've never had.
everyone talks about this place and i get why. so amazing. the pepperoni was the perfect size, the sauce was delicious, and the crust was perfect. I can't wait to go back
Be the first to ReplyGreat Pizza, I loved this place so much, that I Will come
Great Pizza, I loved this place so much, that I Will come back here again! Great friendly staff
Be the first to ReplyWith today being such a cold windy day, I thought a
With today being such a cold windy day, I thought a steaming hot slice of pizza would have been perfect. Approaching the store and seeing a short line, I thought I had lucked out and ordered the spicy pepperoni. Shortly after, my pizza was ready and I took it outside to enjoy my first bite only to find it cold and the sauce room temperature at best! The flavors were there, very delicious, but the temperature just made the whole experience a complete letdown.
Be the first to ReplyBew review bc I decided to order a late night pie for
Bew review bc I decided to order a late night pie for friends and they've been asking for PSP. We ordered the Prince Perfection at 3 am to be delivered. We got the pie on time. It was disgusting. The secret sauce tasted exactly like bad jarred sauce. Filled with preservatives. The crust was inedible. It was dry and tough. If you have any dental work you can kiss them buh bye. We all agreed it we horrible. We threw the pie away. Shame on me throwing fresh food away but I'm embarrassed to give this abomination to others. Why tourist ? Why are you going here ? It's not NYC pizza. It's even bad for Detroit pizza standards. Go to Emmy Squared for the Detroit variety. Anywhere else for NY pizza.
Be the first to ReplyWent yesterday WHAT no line.
Great actually no. Sicilian slice was just average. It was Not crispy or light. They put it in the oven but the slice was cold in the center. There was something off about the flavor. Most people get this loaded with pepperoni. Maybe its that they like.
Be the first to ReplyDelicious pizza, not too long of a wait.
Quick to order. We went in the afternoon to try their famous pizza, and was in and out quick. Definitely worth a try.
Be the first to ReplyI came here on a Sunday around 5pm.
The line only had about 12-15 people in front of us. I knew I wanted to get the Naughty slice (spicy vodka sauce, pepperoni, hot honey, ricotta and fresh mozz) You can see on my slices that the ingredients don't really make it to the end which was a little disappointing. And it's definitely got a spicy kick to it. Tip: if you pay cash, there's a cash discount
Be the first to ReplyA great place for a slice.
Fast and efficient service. A very New York City place. To go joint so don't expect to hang out here
Be the first to ReplyBest pizza in Manhattan.
Can never go wrong with the grandma slice, always crispy with just the right amount of sauce and the basil is the perfect texture with a satisfying crunch that is enhanced if you add pepper flakes.
Be the first to ReplyPizza was delicious.
Service was friendly, small place, no where to eat but standing outside. Line was insane though. Even in the rain the line was wrapped around the corner
Be the first to ReplyHaven't been to Prince Street in many years.
Years ago when they first opened the pizza was great but I assume they fell off since then.I came here on a late night, there was a few pepperoni squares out and the young lady at the register gave me a slice was that had been clearly sitting out for awhile, after I asked her if it was hot which she lied.The pizza was room temperature and the sauce tasted different than what I had remembered. I love spicy, which is was but lacked flavor something was off. Maybe it would have been a lot better if it were fresh. I ended up taking a few bites then throwing the rest out.Probably won't return 1/5 stars
Be the first to ReplyTried the well known, hyped up prince street pizza.
The taste of their famous square pizza was okay but couldn't really distinguish what was different about this pizza. I actually enjoyed their margarita pizza way better. Unfriendly prices for a single slice but ig it's the New York price. When I went they were only accepting cash so that was very inconvenient.
Be the first to ReplyThe legendary Prince Street Pizza! It was fantastic; if the
The legendary Prince Street Pizza! It was fantastic; if the pizza doesn't have thick pepperoni cups filled with oil, I don't want it!Really isn't much to say other than to go try it!
Be the first to ReplyBest pizza I've had in a long time.
Don't expect to sit anywhere. This pizza is life changing.
Be the first to ReplyPrince street pizza is now our new top pizza place in NYC!
Prince street pizza is now our new top pizza place in NYC! We finally braved the ~30-40 min line on a busy Saturday afternoon around 5 for a slice and it was perfect. We love our pizza a little toastier and the bottom of the slice had a very satisfying crunch. The slice has a slight spiciness so be warned. It's not overly cheesy and the pepperoni cups balance the overall flavor very well. We'll definitely be back!
Be the first to ReplyI waited for about 15 mins which was fine it part of the
I waited for about 15 mins which was fine it part of the experience but unfortunately I experienced horrible customer service once I ordered. The guy with the nose rings is extremely rude and as well as the young girl that works the register. I asked for two slices cheese and a margarita slice. The cheese pizza was already sitting (which was only two slices left). The fresh cheese pie came out and I asked if I could have one from that pie instead since it was super hot and fresh. The guy with the nose ring gave me cold slice that was already seating and told me it's all the same. Both employees shouted at me telling me they are all the same. This is the 2nd time I had a bad experience it very unfortunate that this business has been around for many years and workers act this way towards customers. It was simple request was made and my money was spent but the service made my experience all bad. I hope this brings awareness so other customers won't experience this.
Be the first to ReplyI came here because so many people rave about the pizza and
I came here because so many people rave about the pizza and I will say it was good, but just not my favorite. If you're looking for typical New York pizza, i.e. thin and a little greasy, this may not suit your tastebuds. The muzz and pepperoni were great. I just feel like the bread ratio was a lot. Which is simply just not my preference. Overall glad I tried it and I recommend if you go be prepared to stand in a line, but it moves relatively fast. There's also not a lot of standing room inside of the restaurant to eat at the bar so you may have to eat outside or take it to go and eat comfortably elsewhere.
Be the first to ReplyDon't bother ordering from here.
Our pie came burnt and cold ??? Ridiculous. -1 Stars
Be the first to ReplyGreat pizza.
Great atmosphere. Legit Italian American pizza joint. Can't miss if you're in New York and now LA. Love being able to get New York in my mouth out on the west coast. Even great delivered with Goldbelly. First class all around.
Be the first to ReplyHave been wanting to try this pizza for the longest time
Have been wanting to try this pizza for the longest time after seeing all the YouTubers and YouTube pieces on it. It definitely did not disappoint and lived up to the hype! We went around 2pm on a Thursday and there wasn't much of a line, maybe 10 people in front of us and we got our two slices within 10 mins. We got a spicy spring pep slice as well as a margherita Sicilian slice. Both were tremendous, but extra points for the pep slice. Crust is great and has crunch but gives way to a great soft dough, pepperonis are game changers, and sauce and cheese are awesome as well.This is a must try, but I wouldn't wait more than 20-30 minutes for it.
Be the first to ReplyBest Pizza in NYC.
ย Period.Light, balanced, flavorful.Order either the cheese or pepperoni.
Be the first to Replynice pizza ever had, price is little expensive, service was
nice pizza ever had, price is little expensive, service was very nice and fast. I recommend this.
Be the first to Reply